Serta iComfort vs. Tempurpedic: Which Is The Better Mattress?


If there’s one question about mattresses that we get asked time and again, it’s “which is the best: Serta vs Tempurpedic?”

A lot of people will be torn between buying the iComfort (available on Amazon) or Tempurpedic (available on Amazon) mattresses — they’re certainly both at the top of their game in the sleep comfort world.

icomfort mattress vs tempurpedic

The innovators at Tempurpedic have long held the industry crown as the creators and top purveyors of luxury memory foam beds, but due to a recent newcomer to the scene – the equally inventive Serta company – they are in danger of losing their dominance in the market.

Currently both Tempurpedic and Serta are two of the highest quality mattress manufacturers in the world, and they are a popular choice with people searching for a good night’s sleep.

So with these two mattress monarchs battling it out, who deserves the top spot – Serta or Tempurpedic…?

We’ll be comparing two of the best selling products: the Serta iCOMFORT Blue Max 1000 and the Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Contour Supreme Firm.

Let’s get right into it.

Serta vs Tempurpedic: The Mattresses

Good sleep solutions are in high demand right now and Tempurpedic and Serta have some of the hottest options available to consumers — as well as some of the most expensive.

Serta iCOMFORT Blue Max 1000 Plush

The Serta iComfort Blue is one of the company’s most loved mattresses.

serta or tempurpedic

It’s a big mattress, at 13 inches tall and comprises a 5-layered design crafted of ultra premium memory foams:

  • TempActiv Touch Cover
  • TempActiv Max Gel Memory Foam
  • Ultimate Edge Foam Core
  • EverCool Supreme Memory Foam

The major plus of the Serta iComfort is the fact that it’s incredibly  cooling , thanks to the TempActiv Touch Cover which is immediately cool to the touch, and the TempActiv Max Gel Memory Foam, which is infused with millions of gel beads that work to capture, store and dissipate heat throughout the night.

It conforms to the body to give support and relieves pressure points to provide  pain relief  and leave you feeling revitalized every morning. Serta iComfort designs also provide  good motion isolation , so if your partner has a habit of tossing and turning all night it will stand far less chance of interrupting your sleep.

As you’d expect with a mattress at this price point, it’s  incredibly supportive  despite its  plush comfort softness .

The Ultimate Edge Foam Core proves supportive throughout the night and continually reshapes itself to the contours of your body — perfect for easing and comforting toss and turners.

Plus, as inferred by the name, that support extends all the way to the edges of the mattress — not like cheaper mattresses that often become weak and soft after a few months of nightly use.

Not only all that, but the Serta iComfort is versatile and convenient to use. It works with all bed frame types, including box springs, slatted frames and adjustable foundations.

Stand-Out Features

  • 97% of owners would recommend this mattress
  • The official mattress of the National Sleep Foundation
  • Designed and made in the USA
  • Versatile
  • Super supportive
  • Cool throughout the night and cool to the touch
  • Limited 10 year warranty
  • Thick and plush — supremely comfortable
  • Durable — will last for years
  • Memory foam is CertiPUR-US certified

Tempurpedic are famous as the original inventors of memory foam, and their mattresses have really set the standard for the last few years.

icomfort or tempurpedic

Tempurpedic’s mattresses are expensive, there’s no getting around it, but they’re undeniably the best on the market.

This TEMPUR-Contour Supreme mattress is the ideal mattress for those of you that like your mattresses  firm and supportive. 

At 11.5 inches thick, it’s a little thinner than the Serta iComfort above, but it’s just as high quality.

It’s formulated entirely from Tempur material, which includes a ‘Comfort Layer’ — so called because it’s made from Tempur-Adapt material that  transforms according to the contours and temperature of your body , to allow you the best possible night’s sleep.

And just like the Serta iComfort, it promises to keep you cool all night long. That’s due to the SmartClimate System that works to draw moisture away from your body and  keep you cool . Heat dispersal is also encouraged thanks to the base layer of the mattress as well.

The mattress is also encased in the EasyRefresh top cover that’s cool to the touch — as well as being easy to wash and replace thanks to the

Stand-Out Features

  • A soft and durable cover easy to remove, wash and put back on
  • SmartClimate System — moisture wicking fibers to keep sleeping cool
  • Tempur-HD offers high conforming and precise support (in TEMPUR-Contour)
  • Thick and comfortable while being intensely supportive
  • Distributes body weight evenly about the mattress
  • Super responsive material
  • Cool to the touch
  • Ensures undisturbed sleep if you’re sleeping with a partner
When considering an iComfort mattress vs Tempurpedic, it’s a good idea to decide based on whether you prefer plush or firm when it comes to comfort level.

The Serta iComfort is certainly more plush, ideal for the person who wants to feel like they’re sleeping on a cloud.

The Tempurpedic Supreme Contour on the other hand is the perfect firm friend if you require a little more support. Those with bad backs will be particularly well served by the Tempurpedic mattress.

Serta’s gel foam uses more advanced technology and is cooler and more comfortable for the skin, but Tempurpedic have countered this somewhat the SmartClimate System that redistributes heat around the mattress. It’s not quite as cooling as the Serta iComfort but can still be considered a cool night’s sleep.

Put simply, both are fantastic mattresses. But let’s find out the other differences between them…

iComfort Mattress vs Tempurpedic: Prices

Both companies seemingly offer very similar products, but who offers the best value for money – iComfort or Tempurpedic?

Apparently sweet slumber comes at a price, as both brands are priced in at the expensive end of the market.

On their website, Tempurpedic Queen size mattresses are priced from $1699 for a TEMPUR-Cloud Prima mattress all the way up to $4499 for a TEMPUR-Cloud Luxe Breeze.

Serta’s iComfort mattress range is priced between $1299 and $3499 for a standard Queen set (including foundation), according to their website.

Tempurpedic sells foundations and bases separately, so you will need to factor this into the overall final cost of your new bed if you choose them over Serta.

Serta vs Tempurpedic: Reviews

Serta iComfort Reviews

The Positives

  • Comfortable
  • Provides excellent pressure point relief
  • Eases back pain
  • Excellent motion isolation
  • No memory foam odor upon delivery
  • Sleeps cool

The Negatives

  • Although cheaper than other luxury brands like Tempurpedic, undeniably still expensive
  • A decrease in body support and increase in mattress sagging over the long term
Tempurpedic Reviews

The Positives

  • Very durable with no noticeable mattress sagging
  • Comfortable
  • Good motion isolation
  • Reduces back pain
  • Excellent pressure point relief

The Negatives

  • Expensive
  • Memory foam can get a little warm (aside from the Breeze product line)


We spend one-third of our lives asleep (or trying to!) and for some the quest for quality sleep can be a long and complicated one.

Good, reviving sleep free from aches and pains begins with a quality mattress to rest on, and it’s clear that both Serta iComfort and Tempurpedic have an excellent range of mattresses that have already helped thousands of satisfied customers achieve sweet dreams.

The true test of a mattress is down to the individual — so to find out who wins in Serta vs Tempurpedic why not test them both yourself?

Check Serta iComfort’s Price on Amazon Check Tempurpedic’s Price on Amazon

We hope you’ve found our Serta iComfort vs Tempurpedic review helpful. Looking for alternatives? Be sure to visit our mattress reviews section for other great options.

Leave A Reply